New Directions in Critical Theory #47: The Scandal of Reason

A Critical Theory of Political Judgment

New Directions in Critical Theory #47: The Scandal of Reason
Albena Azmanova
RRP:
NZ$ 56.99
Our Price:
NZ$ 47.02
Paperback
h229 x 152mm - 296pg
29 Jun 2021 US
International import eta 10-30 days
9780231153812
Out Of Stock
Currently no stock in-store, stock is sourced to your order
Theories of justice are haunted by a paradox: the more ambitious the theory of justice, the less applicable and useful the model is to political practice; yet the more politically realistic the theory, the weaker its moral ambition, rendering it unsound and equally useless. Brokering a resolution to this "judgment paradox," Albena Azmanova advances a "critical consensus model" of judgment that serves the normative ideals of a just society without the help of ideal theory. Tracing the evolution of two major traditions in political philosophy? critical theory and philosophical liberalism? and the way they confront the judgment paradox, Azmanova critiques prevailing models of deliberative democracy and their preference for ideal theory over political applicability. Instead, she replaces the reliance on normative models of democracy with an account of the dynamics of reasoned judgment produced in democratic practices of open dialogues. Combining Hannah Arendt' s study of judgment with Pierre Bourdieu' s social critique of power relations, and incorporating elements of political epistemology from Kant, Wittgenstein, H. L. A. Hart, Max Weber, and American philosophical pragmatism, Azmanova centers her inquiry on the way participants in moral conflicts attribute meaning to their grievances of injustice. She then demonstrates the emancipatory potential of the model of critical deliberative judgment she forges and its capacity to guide policy making. This model' s critical force yields from its capacity to disclose the common structural sources of injustice behind conflicting claims to justice. Moving beyond the conflict between universalist and pluralist positions, Azmanova grounds the question of "what is justice? " in the empirical reality of "who suffers? " in order to discern attainable possibilities for a less unjust world.

A Political Economy of the Senses: Neoliberalism, Reification, Critique
Capitalism on Edge: How Fighting Precarity Can Achieve Radical Change Without Crisis or Utopia
Crisis Under Critique: How People Assess, Transform, and Respond to Critical Situations
Critical Theory in Critical Times: Transforming the Global Political and Economic Order
Critique on the Couch: Why Critical Theory Needs Psychoanalysis
Death and Mastery: Psychoanalytic Drive Theory and the Subject of Late Capitalism
Democracy in What State?
Fascist Mythologies: The History and Politics of Unreason in Borges, Freud, and Schmitt
Foucault/Derrida Fifty Years Later: The Futures of Genealogy, Deconstruction, and Politics
Hermeneutics as Critique: Science, Politics, Race, and Culture
Media of Reason: A Theory of Rationality
New Directions in Critical Theory #67: Transitional Subjects: Critical Theory and Object Relations
New Directions in Critical Theory: A Time for Critique
New Directions in Critical Theory: Alienation
New Directions in Critical Theory: Avicenna and the Aristotelian Left
New Directions in Critical Theory: Death and Mastery: Psychoanalytic Drive Theory and the Subject of Late Capitalism
New Directions in Critical Theory: End of Progress, The: Decolonizing the Normative Foundations of Critical Theory
New Directions in Critical Theory: Fear of Breakdown: Politics and Psychoanalysis
New Directions in Critical Theory: Imaginal Politics: Images Beyond Imagination and the Imaginary
New Directions in Critical Theory: Left-Wing Melancholia: Marxism, History, and Memory
New Directions in Critical Theory: Political Responsibility: Responding to Predicaments of Power
New Directions in Critical Theory: Politics of Our Selves, The: Power, Autonomy, and Gender in Contemporary Critical The
New Directions in Critical Theory: Power of Tolerance, The: A Debate
New Directions in Critical Theory: Return of Work in Critical Theory, The: Self, Society, Politics
New Directions in Critical Theory: Right to Justification, The: Elements of a Constructivist Theory of Justice
New Directions in Critical Theory: Social Acceleration: A New Theory of Modernity
Political Uses of Utopia: New Marxist, Anarchist, and Radical Democratic Perspectives
Politics of Culture and the Spirit of Critique: Dialogues
Practice of Political Theory, The: Rorty and Continental Thought
Practice of Political Theory, The: Rorty and Continental Thought
Praxis and Revolution: A Theory of Social Transformation
Recognition and Ambivalence
Recognition or Disagreement: A Critical Encounter on the Politics of Freedom, Equality, and Identity
Scandal of Reason, The: A Critical Theory of Political Judgment
Selected Writings on Media, Propaganda, and Political Communication
What is a People?
Wrath of Capital, The: Neoliberalism and Climate Change Politics

Concerned with the links connecting ethical positions and political reality, this ambitious and appealing contribution to critical theory guides our understanding of power and judgment, democracy and justice. Ranging wisely across multiple literatures and considerations, The Scandal of Reason offers compelling arguments about the level, type, and validity of ordered reflection most likely to advance good judgment and decent values under vexing conditions. -- Ira Katznelson, Ruggles Professor of Political Science and History, Columbia University With this original and incisive book, Albena Azmanova develops a new hermeneutic for reconciling two models of reasoning that have long been opposed to one another: contextually sensitive political judgments on the one hand versus procedurally-oriented models of discursive validity on the other. She argues that the more ideal a model of judgment, the less applicable in practice, and the more applicable in practice, the less morally rigorous-this has been the dilemma. She tries to resolve this by developing a model of critical political judgment, sensitive to shared matrices of meaning as well as hierarchies of reference. This is a major contribution to theories of judgment and is also written with flair and humor. -- Seyla Benhabib, Eugene Meyer Professor of Political Science and Philosophy, Yale University Can deliberation avoid reproducing structural injustice? Dissatisfied with standard procedural models of public reason, Albena Azmanova proposes a new approach that foregrounds the ways in which power asymmetries prestructure deliberators' judgments. Combining philosophical rigor with sociological sensitivity, she extends the reach of critique to crucial regions that liberals ignore: namely, the sociocultural frames that simultaneously enable and constrain our capacity to perceive injustices. The result is a fascinating and convincing book that clarifies reason' s ' scandalous' ability to serve both domination and emancipation. -- Nancy Fraser, Henry A. and Louise Loeb Professor of Political and Social Science, the New School for Social Research Albena Azmanova navigates between abstract, universalist conceptions of justice and legitimacy and situated, particularistic claims that disguise their implicit norms. Her work on judgment solves many of the problems of existing theories of deliberative democracy without surrendering normative justification. What is especially valuable in her work is that she transforms deliberative theory in a way that will be more usable for both empirical analysis and political orientation. -- Andrew Arato, Dorothy Hirshon Professor in Political and Social Theory, The New School for Social Research Albena Azmanova identifies what seems to have been a paradox in deliberative theory-that it be either relevant or normative but not both. She resolves this paradox with her own ' critical consensus model,' which shows that we need not give up on social criticism and political relevance in order to develop a theory with normative force. -- Noelle McAfee, Emory University Azmanova' s original and theoretically incisive book reveals new connections between deliberative democracy and judgments about social injustice. Highly relevant for those interested in connecting critical theory to democratic deliberation. -- James Fishkin, director, Center for Deliberative Democracy, Stanford University Moving well beyond the earlier generation of discursive theories, [Azmanova] open[s] up new modalities of politics and provide[s] us with new ways of thinking about them. -- Kevin Olson * Constellations * The Scandal of Reason is an impressive book. It is carefully argued, beautifully written, and thought provoking. * Perspectives on Politics * The problem Azmanova identifies is perennial, and she makes the convincing case that it cannot be ignored. * International Journal of Philosophical Studies *
Albena Azmanova teaches political and social theory at the University of Kent' s Brussels School of International Studies. Her books include Capitalism on Edge: How Fighting Precarity Can Achieve Radical Change Without Crisis or Utopia (Columbia, 2020).
Status: Active
ISBN-13: 9780231153812
Published: 29 Jun 2021
Published In: United States
Imprint: Columbia University Press
Publisher: Columbia University Press
Format: Paperback
Height: 229mm
Width: 152mm
Pages: 296

In stock - for items in stock we aim to dispatch the next business day. For delivery in NZ allow 2-5 business days, with rural taking a wee bit longer.

Locally sourced in NZ - stock comes from a NZ supplier with an approximate delivery of 7-15 business days.

International Imports - stock is imported into NZ, depending on air or sea shipping option from the international supplier stock can take 10-30 working days to arrive into NZ. 

Pre-order Titles - delivery will vary depending on where the title is published, if local stock is available in NZ then 5-7 business days, for international imports it can be 10-30 business days. In all cases we will access the quickest supply option.

Delivery Packaging - we ship all items in cardboard sleeves or by box with either packing paper or corn starch chips. (We avoid using plastics bubble bags)

Tracking - Orders are delivered by track and trace courier and are fully insured, tracking information will be sent by email once dispatched.

View our full Order & Delivery information